For Hazel Whitehead and John Show, the life that has been lost is that of their only child. She was pregnant with Yunkin's baby at the time of Laurie Show's murder. An only child, he is the last of his immediate family. East Lampeter's police chief and a former detective have filed separate lawsuits claiming a book co-authored by convicted killer Lisa Michelle. n March 2, 2023 "The money doesn't matter but he should be made accountable for what he helped to do," she said. Buck wrote herself a late note that day. Yunkin claimed he didnt realize the gravity of what happened. Crime scene experts also testified that no evidence of Show writing any initials in her blood was found, and that other evidence discovered at the crime scene did not corroborate Lambert's story.[6]. Despite the murder, it is the spot of her happiest memories with her daughter, she said, and she would not consider leaving it. This has severely hindered her from seeing . Crucial points in the federal court never will be asked and will be removed from the record by witnesses convenient loss of memory.. In addition, the police and prosecutorial misconduct was not only outrageous but also led directly to the conviction of a woman we have found by clear and convincing evidence to have been actually innocent of first-degree murder., Judy and Leonard Lambert, parents of Lisa Michelle, exit the Federal courthouse, Monday, April 21, 1997, in Philadelphia, after their daughter was found not guilty. If you're unsure of how to do this, click here for a quick guide. While the allegations against the police officers never amounted to charges, a prison guard at SCI Cambridge Springs, Crawford County, was convicted of the rape. Buck was a 17-year-old student at Penn Manor High School in 1991 when she and Lisa Michelle Lambert went inside 16-year-old Laurie Show's East . The two young women burst inside and attacked Laurie. Police said . 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. In the interim, he said he went to McDonalds. Lisa was born on August 23, 1961, at . Select this result to view Lisa Lyn Lambert's phone number, address, and more. Lisa Lambert was born in 1962. Life marched on for Show's parents, John Show and Hazel Whitehead, who lost their only daughter on Dec. 20, 1991. According to Lambert her home life consisted of strict Christian parents with high morals. "It makes you more comfortable to think she's nearby," she said. She also stated that she had attempted to help defend Show against the other two assailants, and that she had tried to pull the victim out of the apartment. are suing the author and publisher of 'Love, Murder, and . Jonathan Majors chats with ET's Nischelle Turner about starring in 'Creed III,' in theaters March 3. I could see how evil some people can be and how they twist things round to blame the victim. Share: Email This BlogThis! Just before Christmas 1991, Lambert and two accomplices schemed a way to attack and kill Show against whom Lambert had developed an unhealthy resentment. As Show was on her way out, Whitehead said she noticed a girl chasing Show around the mall and then push her into wall. Click here if you wish to opt out and view the full site. Laurie Show was a giving girl, she loved her family, she tutored kids in school and had a handful of friends. Witnesses dropped out and evidence was prohibited. Lambert's lawyer argued that the institution had done nothing to stop the assaults and that Lambert's conviction would impede her from having a fair trial. Click here if you wish to opt out and view the full site. The sci-fi family drama, about a mother (Michelle Yeoh) fighting to save the universe [] "Everything Everywhere All at Once" swept the 2023 Gold Derby Film Awards. She is buried at the Bridgeville Evangelical Congregational Cemetery in Narvon, Pa. Dec. 17, 2021. Show's murder helped push forward anti-stalking legislation,[31] with new laws signed into effect in June 1993. Now freed from prison and living in the area, he has become a good bowler and has 302 friends on Facebook. It was only moments later that Lisa Michelle Lambert and Lamberts friend who also had harassed Show, Tabitha Buck, showed up to the condo on 92 Black Oak Drive. He was sentenced on Oct. 10, 1992, to 10 to 20 years in prison and paroled in 2004 at age 33. The bus usually picks her up around that time, said Whitehead. Lisa Michelle Lambert & Tabitha Buck Pt. She had studied at Santa Monica City College and was employed as the Ranch Manager at St. Bonnie's Animal. Updated: 12:59 PM EST January 24, 2017. "I truly believe God has a plan for me. Judge Dalzell on April 15, 1997 freed Lisa Michelle Lambert. Lamberts partner, Tabitha Buck was a 17 year-old student at Penn Manor High School, who had transferred from Conestoga Valley a few months before the murder. She had a belief in God and enjoyed Bible study and Sunday school. Yunkin had been charged with one count of hindering apprehension (prosecution) and committed to prison with $1 million bail for driving the girls to the crime scene. For such a violent crime against Laurie Show, all three suspects should've had defensive wounds but Lisa Lambert had none. RIs# View the profiles of professionals named "Lisa Michelle" on LinkedIn. I know John and Hazel are, as youve pointed out some facts in here that the media has neglected to share. The one who fought the hardest, and loudest, is still sitting in a cell. No one to walk down the aisle. Support local journalism. To the officer, Show confessed the date-rape incident. JN?GrO$>Ji>PAf XG,{&PMB=Yt%.|. But Laurie Show is forever 16, a pretty, dark-haired teen who was looking forward to getting her driver's license and hoped to some day be a nurse or a hairdresser. She has stayed in the same condominium. Now, on the 20th anniversary of the murder, the stark contrast between the two girls is what many people remember most. "It was totally engrossing," Fawcett said, noting that she still thinks about it. Neither he nor Whitehead have run into Yunkin since he was released from prison in 2003. Friends and family may visit from 3:00 to 6:00 p.m. on Monday January 2, 2023, at Leonard Funeral Home & Crematory, 2595 Rockdale Road, where a Funeral Service will begin at 6:00 p.m. with Father Tom McDermott officiating. "It was so senseless, there was absolutely no reason that her life was taken, none what so ever" said Whitehead who, with Show's father, agreed to this interview to mark 20 years since the time they lost their daughter. Dalzell, whose chambers are in the same federal building as Stengel's, declined to comment when contacted about the case. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). In fact, Laurie Show had made a report to police on July 31, 1991 that Yunkin had date raped her. [29] Federal Judge Anita Brody later upheld this verdict. Now a 19-year-old, Lambert's daughter is the same age her mother was at the time of Laurie Show's death. On Dec. 20, 1991, 16-year-old Laurie Show was found in her East Lampeter Township condo with her throat slit, a rope around her neck and multiple stab wounds. Yunkin was ordered to hold the sweatpants up against his body, which were shown to be too short for him, as well as being made of a different fabric from the garment entered into evidence in the 1992 trial. When she told this to the lead investigator at the time, he told her not to dwell on the sighting, and it was forgotten, she testified. Here are the families linked to the case. About a half hour later, the same person called again and told her to meet them at 7 a.m. the next morning at the junior high school. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. She found Show, lying bloody on the bedroom floor. Hazel Show told Lambert that Yunkin had raped her daughter Laurie, and that they might press charges if Lambert continued to harass Laurie. Jack and Lisa Lambert are raising their kids on a 125-acre plot in the rural outpost of Worthington (population: 763), seven miles west of Kittanning. Buck was granted parole on December 21, 2019. It sounds like Lisa was deeply jealous of Laurie. Laurie worked at a store in a local mall, where investigators said Lambert began swearing at her in front of customers regularly. The two see each other regularly but never speak of the case. Hazel would later say that by December her daughter feared for her safety. CALGARY - The mother of Lisa Michelle Mitchell is speaking about her loss, days after police confirmed her daughter was murdered. Show and Yunkin had planned to see fireworks the Saturday before the Fourth of July back in 91. "It hurts," he said. It was 7:07, I wrote the teacher a note that said, I was here, if you need me I will come back,' added Whitehead. Testimony later reveals . Whatever relationship Laurie and Yunkin had ended after that week. The detectives testimony denied allegations that evidence had been tampered with. The federal appeals court ruled that Dalzell should have never heard the case, as Lambert had not exhausted her state appeals prior to going before him. [12] Another exhibit was a letter from Lambert to Yunkin, in which Lambert states, "I know I'm not an angel, but Lawrence, I never got mad enough to kill. Not too long after they met, Lambert starting giving Show a hard time concerning her appearance. The neighbor rushed upstairs and reached for the phone, it didnt work for the chord was tied around Lauries legs. Wiki User. Yunkins story already had been disproven after suspicion from the prosecution and defense caused his plea agreement to be reconsidered. Laurie Show at 16 years old. She was born July 27, 1958 in San Francisco, CA. The convicted killer earned a college degree behind bars, where she has spent almost all of her adult life, save for a 10-month period of freedom. If you are using Chrome and keep getting redirected to this page, then turn sync off. Good luck. Hazel Whitehead left her home 20 years ago today for what she thought was an appointment with her daughter's guidance counselor at school. Michelle did it. endstream 3,789 records for Lisa Lambert. [9] Initial statements from the three claimed that Yunkin had dropped Lambert and Buck off at Show's house, where the two girls murdered Show. 19eO1#9A#Q2~! gffh0c/+m?Tk/vr^Z'8*Itis>T1r{uV^Y4?u J{O"o8Of8$OO-`7_&w0! On that day, he asked Dalzell if Lambert could be reimprisoned or placed on bail during her pending appeal. The Student News Magazine of Penn Manor HS. For those not familiar with the case from 1991, we refer you to todays' LNP article "In a killer's words: Lisa Michelle Lambert, nearly 25 years since Laurie Show's murder, claims innocence in new book.". "I think all the more she didn't do what she was convicted of.". Lisa Michelle Lambert is currently incarcerated at Massachusetts Correc. @LisaMichellela1. No grandchildren to hold. After 28 years behind bars, Tabitha Buck, a midstate woman who was 17 when she killed a high school classmate is slated for release on Dec. 21. Her murderer, 19 year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert. " "Girl On Fire, Michelle Lambert, makes . [6] Hazel Show was not at home at the time of the attack, having been duped by the killers into going to the high school to speak to a guidance counselor. Attorney John A. Kenneff referred their cases to the U.S. Attorney Office for further investigation. The release sent shockwaves throughout the community, but Lambert, her family and her attorneys were thrilled. Lauries last words, Michelle did it. She was born July 27, 1958 in San . By then, the harassment had begun. [25], Lambert's lawyers presented correspondence between Lambert and Yunkin that they claimed proved that Lambert had not been involved in the murder and that Yunkin had asked her to lie for him. ounK9;^hwlQRDS;lve]?G'[T6[7 r2(^JL j"Q(@b\lbVN&'!7+:ofpKvg3wJ:P.zKKKb8FF@;V3dj7v`I k/Dx"t*s\_V@3Un#U8z:M2Rcw*@/d2D,k+awO$kE|EM\w,2#I64^!u>B"y$&j{rP`@lXsnj]@=K uV2;2fPIEF#* If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. The couple divorced in 2009, local court records show. He has a Facebook page, which shows a tattoo of a purple ribbon with the words "Live Strong" and "Just Do It.". She was found guilty of second degree murder and sentenced to life in prison. Her mother Hazel Show had driven to an early morning meeting that turned out to be a prank and returned to discover her daughter laying on the floor in her bedroom. Clear & Convincing: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Vs Lauries parents are truly brave people and I wish them all the best. 416 pp. TO READ A DOCUMENT, SIMPLY CLICK ONCE ON HIGHLIGHTED AREA & THIS DOCUMENT WILL OPEN FOR YOU TO READ. His testimony would be just the first of many things Lambert used to cast doubt on the original proceedings while on appeal. Her attorney: Christina Rainville. Shortly after, Show bled to death. She noticed that Yunkin and Lambert were parked up front. Lambert doggedly appealed her case. The time they spent together before then, Yunkin date-raped Show. Newspaper accounts from the time noted that Dalzell chuckled and peered over his bifocals at Madenspacher, saying, "Motion denied.". Looking at pictures of Laurie, she always had a smile on her face and you could see that she was just a nice kid who didnt deserve this. Lambert finally gets the rope around her neck, but Laurie begins struggling again. [33] Lambert received a $35,000 settlement, with the guard accused of assaulting her serving a .mw-parser-output .frac{white-space:nowrap}.mw-parser-output .frac .num,.mw-parser-output .frac .den{font-size:80%;line-height:0;vertical-align:super}.mw-parser-output .frac .den{vertical-align:sub}.mw-parser-output .sr-only{border:0;clip:rect(0,0,0,0);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px}1+12- to 3-year sentence. Part of the reason Lambert was an immediate suspect in the killing was that there were allegations of months of harassment and stalking prior to Shows death. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. Greenberg remains retired, she said. [2] Her classmates Lisa Michelle Lambert, Tabitha Buck, and Lawrence "Butch" Yunkin were all subsequently charged with her murder. Vicki Vellios Briner | Special to PennLiveVicki Vellios Briner | Special to PennLive, When Hazel Show found her daughter on the floor, covered in blood, the last thing she heard was Michelle did it. When Whitehead appeared at the school, the person she was allegedly supposed to meet with wasnt there. By ABC News. The Philadelphia attorney who handled Lambert's defense appeal moved to Vermont, where she now works on the other side of the lawyering aisle, prosecuting sex crimes. Buck and 18-year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert lured Show's mother out of their apartment and slashed Show's throat. [22] Judge Lawrence F. Stengel oversaw the trial, he is also Lambert's trial judge from her first trial in 1992. *g Stengel convicted Lambert of first-degree murder. (Page 4) She is an electrifying performer as well as a phenomenal songwriter, sultry vocalist and virtuoso violinist. Buck knocked on the door, the two forced their way in and Laurie was killed in a terrible struggle. Whitehead and Show also have not heard much about Buck in recent years. endobj 308 0 obj << /Encoding 309 0 R /BaseFont /Courier /Name /F0 /Subtype /Type1 /Type /Font >> endobj 309 0 obj << /BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding /Type /Encoding /Differences [ 32 /space ] >> endobj 1 0 obj << /MediaBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Resources << /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ] /Font << /F0 308 0 R >> >> /Contents 2 0 R /Parent 285 0 R /Type /Page /Thumb 188 0 R /CropBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Rotate 0 >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Length 1284 /Filter [ /FlateDecode ] >> stream Different judges hearing the case felt differently about the appeals. [23], Lambert now testified that Yunkin had participated in the murders, choking Show. Yunkin returned to Garden Spot about two years after he left prison and continued bowling there until a fire destroyed the alley this summer. She notified Whitehead and the police were called. It was December 19, when Whitehead got a phone call at work. Now 48 and living in Bennington County in southern Vermont, Rainville said the Lambert case still deeply disturbs her, as does the fact that Lambert remains in prison. : NO. LISA MICHELLE LAMBERT : CIVIL ACTION: v. :: MRS. CHARLOTTE BLACKWELL, : SUPT., et al. Laurie didnt want to hit her, she (Lambert) was pregnant.. Episode #14 - Lisa Michelle Lambert. Lisa Michelle Lambert. Decision by Federal Judge Stewart B Balzell overturning conviction of Lisa Michelle Lambert for 1991 murder of Laurie Shaw and, in unprecedented act, barring Pennsylvania from retrying her, has . saw the movie this morning terrible thing to happen with loosing a child, at least the mother was able to have her last moments before she passed, but god is taking care of her now and we will all be togather some day. "It makes me feel good," he said, his voice breaking. Official Account ran by best friend of Lisa and Lisa herself. I'm Lisa Michelle Pacillas, An Experienced Digital Assets Trader, Investor & Portfolio Manager. Learn more about your ad choices. "Life goes on," she said. The elements of it - the teenage love triangle, the "lurid allegations" of prosecutorial misconduct - made it a riveting case. [email protected]. Along with that, Lamberts attorneys shared more than two dozen examples of investigative and prosecutorial misconduct. Error! The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. It is not known where she lives. As Laurie leaned a little bit further over, Tabitha saw her reach for a pair of scissors and knocked them out her reach. Over the next decade, Lamberts appeals bounced around, including at one point landing back at Dalzell, who again swore to release her. Everybody says Laurie dated him, they werent dates, confirmed Whitehead. Lisa is related to Katherine Anne Stevens and William J Lambert as well as 2 additional people. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. Thanks for sharing. PennLive file photoHarrisburg Patriot-News. In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, 18-year-old Lisa Michelle Lambert waged a months-long campaign of harassment against 16-year-old Laurie Show in 1991. Yunkin agreed to testify against Lambert, stating that she and Buck had slit Show's throat after the two had punctured one of Show's lungs. Whitehead told Show that she was called to the school. Michelle Lambert is a genre-defying 21st century talent with a lot on her mind!". :n`@sH%8J*Z{mGOh[y+Nls@"DiR~.-2e2*N/y dmvTlI-79B[6[uY0{TS]9R>#h;~u_)`w[@F%Rlluq$95 yof@Bkb4VS=:v>FrOi]/G c~2! The meeting was actually a ploy from the girls to get her out of the house while Lambert and Buck went to play a prank on Laurie. Investigators believed Lambert, along with 17-year-old Tabitha Buck, were dropped off at Lauries home by Yunkin early on Dec. 20. The Lambert case consumed three years of her life, she said. Other judges felt Lamberts claims were nonsense and unproven. It was a rough moment but Madenspacher, now a Lancaster County judge, said he was "virtually 100 percent certain" at the time that the full court would reverse Dalzell's decision. `"SD.$Ws|.\Bi>M;s Gt$mS?$~.PE1H~[''|cGx K=3Yyj3k+#4 ^B*4 xxJ> endstream endobj 306 0 obj << /MediaBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Resources << /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ] /Font << /F0 308 0 R >> >> /Contents 307 0 R /Parent 285 0 R /Type /Page /Thumb 187 0 R /CropBox [ 0 0 611 791 ] /Rotate 0 >> endobj 307 0 obj << /Length 1417 /Filter [ /FlateDecode ] >> stream Her body was discovered in her Lancaster, Pennsylvania, home by her mother Hazel Show with her throat having been slit. All Lambert wanted to do, she said, was cut Shows hair as a mean trick.. [14], Lambert was initially incarcerated at Cambridge Springs State Correctional Institution, while Buck was sent to Muncy State Correctional Institution. Rainville said she remains in touch with Lambert, and communicated with her as recently as a few weeks ago. She has bounced around, spending time in prisons in Pennsylvania, Delaware, New Jersey and Massachusetts. In 1997, Lamberts appeal went in front of U.S. District Judge Stewart Dalzell. It likely will never be clear exactly who did what that morning of Dec. 20, 1991. "I know, technically, she's in heaven, but sometimes I think she's saying, 'Hey mom, I'm still here. Her boyfriend, Lawrence Yunkin, who drove the killers to Shows house, pleaded guilty to third-degree murder, was sentenced to 10 to 20 years in prison and was paroled in 2004. This story touched my heart, after I saw the film on the True Movies Channel. Yunkin and Lambert got back together shortly after the holiday. The case is perhaps the county's best-known murder case. Bucks chance for freedom came via a 2012 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that nixed automatic life prison terms for juveniles convicted of murder. [17], A huge amount of Evidence provided at the hearing included the sweatpants entered into the 1992 proceeding as well as correspondence between Yunkin and Lambert where Yunkin admits in his own handwriting that he and Tabitha Buck killed Laurie Show and asked Lambert to take blame for him, because she'll get less time because she is a female. [10] Lambert and Buck would later recant their initial statements, with Lambert claiming that an abusive Yunkin had encouraged her to harass and assault Show. In separate proceedings, Buck was found guilty and also sentenced to life in prison. It's her reminder that he's out there, and that he has to think of her daughter from time to time, she said. Show, 60, retired from his job working for a farm machinery manufacturer a few years ago, but then got called back to work. [6] Dalzell also barred the state of Pennsylvania from re-trying Lambert. Yunkin pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 10 to 20 years for his part in the murder - driving the two young women back and forth and helping to get rid of evidence. She did not know the call was a ruse to get her out of the house. The problems between the two began in July 1991, when Lambert and Yunkin briefly split after months of dating, investigators said at the time. The highest court refused to hear Lambert's case in 2005. Tuesday marks the 20th anniversary of the murder of 16-year-old Laurie Show, shown here in a file photo. Any other time they are nosy busy bodies, but that morning they chose not to go in and see whats wrong, said a choked-up Whitehead. Yunkin admitted to beating Lambert, but she also said he was controlling the clothes she wore and how she behaved. The Principal working at the time was in shock and the concern was how this would make Penn Manor look.. LANCASTER, PA. Two men who investigated the 1991 murder of Laurie Show in East Lampeter Twp. Her parents, Leonard and Judy, obtained custody of the child. The police quickly fingered three participants in the heinous crime: Lawrence "Butch" Yunkin as the getaway driver, Tabitha Buck as the one . Yunkin went back to Lambert, who eventually became pregnant. Instead, as the 10th anniversary of Laurie Show's murder approaches, her family faces Lisa Ann Lambert, 61, of Dubuque, Iowa, passed away on December 28, 2022, at home. Lotter was handed a death sentence after being convicted of killing 21-year-old Brandon Teena, Lisa Lambert and Phillip Devine at a farmhouse in Nebraska in 1993. Today, he'll carry a single rose to the cemetery where his daughter is buried. PennLive file photo Harrisburg . Most likely she still has no remorse for her actions. Photo courtesy of LancasterOnline. Show got away and met her mother outside the mall. "You have to do your best to continue to do what you can to make your life better and to help others. which led to Buck being resentenced in 2017. If you disable cookies, this site will not work properly. She is buried at the Bridgeville Evangelical Congregational Cemetery in Narvon, Pa. Dec. 17, 2021. Buck originally was sentenced to life in prison for the Dec. 20, 1991 murder of 16-year-old Laurie Show in Lancaster Countys Lampeter Township. Another time, Laurie told her mother that Buck threatened her at the mall. Taylor Goldberg, So nice of you to remember Laurie Show, a young lady who well deserved a fulfilling life, but heartless bullies denied her the opportunity. Photo provided by the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections. . Incredible article Taylor, were all so proud of you. [25] He also testified that he had seen a police officer, who matched one of the descriptions Lambert gave of her alleged rapists, give her a "threatening glare" at a local festival. Lambert's time in prison, however, has not gone smoothly. Tabitha Buck testified that she got Laurie to open up the door that day and that she sat on Laurie's legs, while Michelle slit her throat. Former Penn Manor Principal Jan Mindish recalled Buck coming late to school that day. She specializes in the prosecution of child sex offenders, work she finds satisfying. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). In that time, police said Lambert got into the home with Buck, cornered Laurie and ultimately held her down and repeatedly stabbed her. The photograph at left is of Tabitha Buck when she was arrested for the 1991 murder of Laurie Show. Hundreds of witnesses and pieces of evidence were expected from the defense, but the hearing did not go as planned. This was a beautifully written article, Taylor. At the end of the trial, Stengel found Lambert guilty and sentenced her to life in prison. At the other end of the spectrum, according to people that knew her, was the trash-talking, heavily made up, sometimes violent provocateur, Lisa Michelle Lambert. [15] Yunkin received a lesser sentence for his testimony and was granted parole in 2003. Both of his parents have died since Laurie's death. The one allegation that helped solidify Dalzells opinion on the case came from Hazel Show a few days into the appeal hearing. Not too long after that incident, Show noticed that Lambert was waiting for her outside the shop where she worked. Whitehead said she has worked hard not to become angry. Shows mother found her dying daughter, who was able to identify her killers. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup. She had so many hopes and dreams, all taken away at the age of 16. ". LISAMICHELLELA1@TWITTER. The three suspects and Lancaster County prosecutors agree on only two things: Laurie Show was killed, and all three suspects were involved in some way or another.